diff --git a/ec1f-administrator-observability-and-management-strategy.md b/ec1f-administrator-observability-and-management-strategy.md index 02ce2d5..4a7ee9b 100644 --- a/ec1f-administrator-observability-and-management-strategy.md +++ b/ec1f-administrator-observability-and-management-strategy.md @@ -446,3 +446,27 @@ The current phased roadmap above is **SUPERSEDED** pending proper planning: - Deliverable: `docs/research/nip-86-implementation-options.md` committed - Next: Phase 0 Track B (nostr-relay-builder user storage events) - deferred for now - Ready to proceed with Phase 1 implementation + +### 2026-01-15 [Session 11:05] +- **Critical architectural decision:** Identified gap in design - NIP-86 is for actions, not queries +- Researched how to return sensitive data to authenticated users (admins and regular users) +- Launched 3 parallel research subagents: + 1. NIP-86 query response patterns in spec and rust-nostr + 2. Pyramid relay admin patterns (real-world implementation) + 3. Feasibility of pyramid-style approach with rust-nostr +- Key findings from research: + - ✅ NIP-86 spec uses HTTP POST/response (NOT Nostr events for query results) + - ✅ Pyramid uses ephemeral events to specific WebSocket connections for queries + - ❌ nostr-relay-builder does NOT support connection-specific messaging + - ❌ Pyramid approach requires forking nostr-relay-builder or custom WebSocket handler +- **Decision: Use HTTP-based NIP-86 for all queries and actions** + - Queries: HTTP GET/POST with NIP-98 auth → JSON response + - Actions: HTTP POST with NIP-98 auth → JSON response + - Both admin and user queries use same pattern + - Simpler, standard, no framework modifications needed +- Deliverables committed: + - `docs/research/nip-86-query-responses.md` - NIP-86 spec analysis + - `docs/research/pyramid-admin-patterns.md` - Pyramid implementation study + - `docs/research/pyramid-style-queries-design.md` - Feasibility analysis for rust-nostr +- **Next:** Update strategy document to reflect HTTP-based approach for queries +- Phase 0 research complete, ready to finalize architecture and proceed to Phase 1