A bash function returns its last command's status, so one ending in a log
call returns 0 whatever it did, and a caller written as `if func` or
`func || fail` has a gate that cannot fire. This tree found two in one
day: run_chaos ended in record, making every chaos row unconditionally
green since 2026-03-09, and build_fips_for_e2e ended in log, letting five
end-to-end legs test the previous commit's binary and report green. Both
were repaired one at a time. This is the rule that catches the next one.
What it enforces is a contract, not a bug hunt: a function whose status a
caller tests must end in an explicit return rather than leaving its
success value to whatever the last log call produced. That distinction is
deliberate and worth stating, because all three instances found in the
tree were benign — each failure path already returned early, so the
trailing echo reported a real success. Reading the function is the only
way to know that, and the next edit that puts an unguarded command before
the final log converts the benign shape into the defect with nothing to
notice. An explicit return costs a line and makes the class unreachable.
The three are given one here.
Scoped on the call sites rather than the definitions, the same way
check-log-strings.py scopes on what a grep reads rather than what its file
mentions: 315 functions scanned, 42 end in a log call, and only the ones
whose status something consumes are reported. A function that ends by
reporting and is called for its output is idiomatic and is left alone.
Without that scoping the finding list would be 42 long and would stop
being read.
Validated by construction rather than by a green run: injecting a copy of
build_fips_for_e2e's exact shape — unguarded docker cp, then a log as the
last statement, with a `|| { ...; return 1; }` caller — makes the checker
report it and exit 1.
Wired into both runners beside the parity and log-string checks.
Two runs on one host destroyed each other's containers, producing
mid-test "No such container" failures that look like real defects. The
automated builder runs a full local CI on the same box every few minutes,
so the machine is contended almost always and this has red-ed both a hand
run and an automated gate.
Two independent causes are fixed here. Container names were hardcoded, and
docker names are global rather than scoped by compose project, so two runs
collided on the same name; every name now takes an optional suffix that
the harness sets from the run id. And the cleanup sweep matched a label
shared by every run, so one run's teardown force-removed another's
containers; resources now also carry a per-run label and the sweep can be
narrowed to it.
A third hazard turned up that was not in the original report: the sidecar
suite passes explicit compose project names, which override the run-scoped
project and put it outside the shared prefix entirely. Its project names,
network, and derived container references are now scoped too.
Both are default-off. With the suffix unset, names render exactly as they
do today and a bare compose invocation is unchanged, which is what keeps
the hosted CI and the documentation correct. A cleanup run with no run id
still reaps everything, which is what a manual "clear the box" wants.
The literal-name sweep was not sufficient: six scripts build container
names dynamically from node labels, and two suites create their own
containers outside compose. Those are handled at their construction sites.
Verified: syntax check on all modified scripts; compose validation on
every modified file with the suffix both set and unset; and a synthetic
two-run reproduction that shows the old cleanup destroying a bystander run
and the new one leaving it alone.
Known gap: subnets are still hardcoded, so two concurrent full runs will
still collide on address-pool overlap. That fix reaches into topology
configs, chaos scenarios, diagrams and production source, so it is left
for its own change rather than half-done here.
Cover the previously untested overlay advert publish/relay/consume
round-trip. The bilateral publish/subscribe path was a v0.3.0 release
gap: malformed adverts could panic consumers, broken signatures could
go undetected, and reverse-direction subscription was unverified.
Adds testing/nat/scripts/nostr-relay-test.sh (290 lines):
Phase 1+2 (combined): wait_for_peers on both nodes; pass on
bidirectional advert publish/subscribe round-trip + dial completed;
ping6 both directions confirms TUN-level reachability.
Phase 3 (malformed advert resilience): stdlib-only Python WebSocket
client publishes a syntactically valid Schnorr-signed Kind-37195
event whose `content` is gibberish (cannot deserialize as
OverlayAdvert). The relay enforces BIP-340 signature validity, so the
event reaches the consumers (rather than being dropped at the relay)
— a trivially-junk content payload is the right adversarial input.
Required ~80 lines of stdlib-only secp256k1 + BIP-340 in the script
(no new container deps). Asserts pidof fips on both nodes after the
publish, scans logs for panic markers, re-pings to prove the existing
peer link survives.
testing/nat/docker-compose.yml: new profile nostr-publish-consume
with two daemon services (nostr-pub-a 172.31.10.20, nostr-pub-b
172.31.10.21) on shared-lan, reusing the existing strfry relay
(172.31.10.30:7777) and STUN service (172.31.10.40:3478).
testing/nat/scripts/generate-configs.sh: 2-line allowlist update so
the new scenario flows through the existing config generator (rather
than forking a parallel one). Generated node-{a,b}.yaml + npubs.env
smoke-tested cleanly.
testing/ci-local.sh: NOSTR_RELAY_SUITES=(nostr-publish-consume)
array, run_nostr_publish_consume runner, dispatch in run_integration
and run_suite. Mirrors existing run_nat shape.
.github/workflows/ci.yml: one matrix row + 3 steps in the integration
job, gated on matrix.type == 'nostr-publish-consume'. Consumes the
same fips-linux artifact and fips-test:latest image as the existing
NAT suites.
Tor/TCP transport variants kept out of v0.3.0 scope; the structure
leaves room for nostr-publish-consume-tcp/-tor siblings later without
disturbing this baseline.
Johnathan Corgan