After rekey cutover, frames encrypted with the old session can still
arrive during the 10s drain window. These carry large sender timestamps
from the old session, producing enormous transit deltas that spike the
EWMA jitter estimator (observed 2,000-7,000ms spikes on UDP links).
Add a time-based grace period (DRAIN_WINDOW_SECS + 5s = 15s) after
rekey that suppresses jitter updates until drain-window frames have
flushed. Baselines still update every frame so calculation resumes
cleanly after grace expires.
Fixes#10
Rekey dual-initiation race (FMP + FSP):
When both sides' rekey timers fire simultaneously on high-latency links
(Tor ~700ms RTT), both msg1s cross in flight before dampening can
suppress the second initiation. Each node acts as both initiator and
responder, with set_pending_session() from the responder path destroying
the initiator's in-progress state. Each side ends up with a
pending_new_session from a different Noise handshake, causing AEAD
verification failure after cutover and link death. Fix: deterministic
tie-breaker in both FMP msg1 handler and FSP SessionSetup handler
(smaller NodeAddr wins as initiator). Also guard against pending session
overwrite from retransmitted msg1s.
Parent selection SRTT gate:
Peers without MMP RTT data are excluded from parent candidacy via
has_srtt() filter, preventing freshly reconnected peers from appearing
artificially attractive. First-RTT triggers immediate parent re-eval.
The gate in evaluate_parent() skips unmeasured candidates when any peer
has cost data, but falls back to default cost 1.0 during cold start
when no peer has MMP data yet.
Auto-reconnect on all peer removal paths:
The excessive-decryption-failure and peer-restart epoch-mismatch removal
paths were missing schedule_reconnect() calls, causing auto-connect peers
to be permanently abandoned after those events.
Control socket accessibility:
Socket and parent directory chowned to root:fips with mode 0770/0750 so
group members can use fipsctl/fipstop without root.
Log level changes:
Default RUST_LOG changed to debug in systemd service files. "Unknown
session index" log reduced from debug to trace.
The FSP XK rekey handshake has a race condition where the initiator
can cut over (K-bit flip) and send data encrypted with the new session
before msg3 reaches the responder. The responder has no pending session
yet, so K-bit detection fails and packets are dropped.
Defer FSP initiator cutover by 2 seconds after handshake completion
(FSP_CUTOVER_DELAY_MS) to give msg3 time to traverse the mesh. FMP
(IK, 2 messages) is unaffected since the responder completes during
msg1 processing.
Also fix MMP metric corruption after rekey cutover: the new session
starts with counter 0 but MMP state carries highest_counter and
GapTracker.expected_next from the old session, producing false
reorder counts, jitter spikes, and invalid OWD trends. Add
reset_for_rekey() methods that clear counter-dependent state while
preserving RTT estimates.
Additional fixes:
- Remove stale peers_by_index entry on abandon_rekey error path
- Replace redundant peers_by_index inserts with debug assertions
verifying the pre-registration invariant
- Tighten rekey integration test to zero tolerance (was 4 failures)
Implement periodic full rekey at both protocol layers using fresh DH
key exchanges. Uses the existing K-bit flag (FLAG_KEY_EPOCH /
FSP_FLAG_K) to coordinate cutover between peers.
FMP layer (IK pattern):
- ActivePeer gains rekey state: pending/previous sessions, K-bit epoch
tracking, drain window, dampening timer
- Handshake state stored on ActivePeer with msg1 sent on existing link
- Encrypted frame handler detects K-bit flips, promotes pending
sessions, falls back to previous session during drain
- Handshake handlers distinguish rekey from new connections using
addr_to_link lookup with identity-based fallback
- Free all session indices (current, rekey, pending, previous) on
peer removal
FSP layer (XK pattern):
- SessionEntry gains parallel rekey fields with XK-specific state
for the 3-message handshake
- Route availability check before FSP rekey initiation
- Encrypted session handler adds K-bit flip detection and dual-session
decrypt fallback
- SessionSetup/Ack/Msg3 handlers extended for rekey paths
Defense-in-depth:
- Consecutive decryption failure detector (threshold=20) triggers
forced peer removal instead of waiting for link-dead timeout
- Identity-based rekey detection as fallback when addr_to_link
doesn't match (e.g., TCP ephemeral ports)
Configuration: RekeyConfig with enabled flag, after_secs (default 120),
and after_messages (default 65536) thresholds.
Logging: info for successful K-bit cutover completions, warn for
failures, debug for intermediate handshake steps, trace for routine
operations (resends, drain cleanup).
Rekey lifecycle:
1. Timer/counter fires -> initiator starts new handshake
2. Old session continues handling traffic during handshake
3. Handshake completes -> initiator cuts over, flips K-bit
4. Responder sees flipped K-bit -> promotes new session
5. Both keep old session for 10s drain window
6. After drain, old session discarded
Integration test: Docker-based multi-phase test exercising both FMP
and FSP rekey with aggressive timers (35s). Verifies connectivity
across all 20 directed pairs survives two consecutive rekey cycles.
Includes rekey topology, docker-compose profile, and CI matrix entry.
Increase ping test convergence wait from 3s to 5s for CI reliability.
The link-dead check required last_recv_time to be Some, so peers that
completed a handshake but never sent any data back (last_recv_time =
None) were silently skipped and lived forever as zombies. Fall back to
session_start when no frame has ever been received.
Implement TCP transport for FIPS enabling firewall traversal and serving
as the foundation for future Tor transport. This is the first
connection-oriented transport in the system.
Key design decisions:
- FMP header-based framing: reuses existing 4-byte FMP common prefix for
packet boundary recovery with zero framing overhead
- Session survives TCP reconnection: Noise/MMP/FSP state bound to npub,
not TCP connection; MMP liveness is sole authority for peer death
- Connect-on-send: fresh connection on first send, transparent reconnect
- close_connection() trait method for cross-connection deduplication cleanup
New transport files:
- src/transport/tcp/mod.rs: TcpTransport, connection pool, accept loop
- src/transport/tcp/stream.rs: FMP-aware stream reader (shared with Tor)
Modified: transport trait (close_connection), TcpConfig, TransportHandle
match arms, create_transports(), initiate_connection() for connection-
oriented links, cross-connection tie-breaker cleanup, design docs.
Tree announce loop and TCP stability fixes:
- Preserve tree announce rate-limit state across reconnection: carry
forward last_tree_announce_sent_ms when a peer reconnects so the
rate-limit window isn't reset to zero
- Drop oversize TCP packets at sender: pre-send MTU check returns
MtuExceeded instead of writing to the stream, preventing receiver-side
connection teardown and reset-reconnect cycles
Chaos harness:
- TCP transport support: tcp_edges/has_tcp/tcp_peers in SimTopology,
transport-aware config_gen with per-edge transport type, TCP port 443,
pure-TCP node support
- Include all non-Ethernet edges in directed_outbound()
- Fix netem/links log messages to say "IP-based" instead of "UDP"
- Add tcp-chain, tcp-only, and tcp-mesh scenario files
Static harness:
- Transport-aware config generation (get_default_transport, transport_port)
- TCP transport injection via Python post-processing
- Add tcp-chain topology and docker-compose profile
Bump rand (0.8→0.10), rtnetlink (0.14→0.20), tun (0.7→0.8),
simple-dns (0.9→0.11), socket2 (0.5→0.6), and criterion (0.5→0.8).
Migrate all rand call sites: thread_rng()→rng(), gen()→random(),
gen_range()→random_range(), RngCore→Rng trait. Work around secp256k1
0.30 requiring rand 0.8 by generating random bytes directly and
constructing SecretKey from slice.
Migrate rtnetlink to builder-based API: LinkSetRequest replaced with
LinkUnspec builder + change(), RouteAddRequest replaced with
RouteMessageBuilder.
Remove bloom benchmark (criterion 0.8 incompatible with old harness
config).
Add per-peer replay suppression counter to ActivePeer. Log the first 3
replay detections at DEBUG, then suppress with a one-time notice. Emit
a summary count on session replacement or peer removal.
Non-replay decryption errors continue to be logged unconditionally.
Cost-based parent selection:
- Replace depth-only parent selection with effective_depth = depth + link_cost
- link_cost computed from locally measured MMP metrics: etx * (1.0 + srtt_ms / 100.0)
- Prevents bottleneck subtrees in heterogeneous networks where a LoRa link
at depth 1 would otherwise always beat fiber at depth 2
- Configurable hysteresis (default 0.2) prevents marginal parent switches
- Configurable hold-down timer (default 30s) suppresses re-evaluation
after parent switch
- Mandatory switches (parent lost, root change) bypass both safeguards
- Link costs passed as HashMap parameter to keep TreeState pure
Periodic re-evaluation:
- evaluate_parent() was only called on TreeAnnounce receipt or parent loss;
after tree stabilization, link degradation went undetected
- Added timer-based re-evaluation (reeval_interval_secs, default 60s) that
calls evaluate_parent() from the tick handler with current MMP link costs
- Respects existing hold-down and hysteresis safeguards
- Short-circuits when disabled or <2 peers
Design documentation:
- Update 7 design docs to reflect cost-based parent selection
- Replace depth-only algorithm descriptions with effective_depth model
- Replace rejected cumulative path cost spec with local-only design rationale
- Rewrite Example 2 (heterogeneous links) for local-only cost model
- Update config docs: parent_switch_threshold replaced by parent_hysteresis,
hold_down_secs, reeval_interval_secs
Chaos simulation enhancements:
- fips_overrides with deep merge for per-scenario FIPS config customization
- Explicit topology algorithm for deterministic test graphs
- Control socket querying via fipsctl for tree/MMP snapshot collection
- Edge existence validation in netem manager
- Per-link netem policy overrides
- 9 new chaos scenarios covering cost avoidance, depth-vs-cost tradeoffs,
stability, mixed topologies, periodic re-evaluation, and bottleneck parent
12 new unit tests, 667 total passing, clippy clean.
Each node generates a random 8-byte startup epoch, encrypted inside
both Noise IK handshake messages (msg1 and msg2). When a peer's msg1
arrives with a different epoch than the stored value, the node tears
down the stale session and processes the msg1 as a new connection,
enabling near-instant restart detection instead of the 30-second
dead timeout.
Wire format impact:
- msg1: 82 -> 106 bytes (added 24-byte encrypted epoch after ss DH)
- msg2: 33 -> 57 bytes (added 24-byte encrypted epoch after se DH)
- Wire msg1: 90 -> 114 bytes, wire msg2: 45 -> 69 bytes
Sends a 1-byte encrypted heartbeat (0x51) to each peer every 10s.
If no frame is received from a peer within 30s, the peer is removed
via remove_active_peer(), triggering tree reconvergence, coord cache
flush, and bloom filter recomputation.
This fixes the critical bug where UDP peers that silently died
(e.g., container stopped) were never detected or removed, leaving
the spanning tree permanently stale.
Both intervals are configurable via node.heartbeat_interval_secs
and node.link_dead_timeout_secs.
Add message-level retry for Noise IK handshake within the 30s timeout
window. Previously, a lost msg1 or msg2 required the full timeout to
expire before cleanup and retry. Under 10% bidirectional loss (~19%
per attempt), this made connection establishment unreliable.
Initiator resends stored msg1 bytes with exponential backoff (1s, 2s,
4s, 8s, 16s — 5 resends). Responder stores msg2 and resends on
duplicate msg1 receipt. Duplicate msg2 at initiator drops silently
via existing pending_outbound cleanup.
Config: handshake_resend_interval_ms (1000), handshake_resend_backoff
(2.0), handshake_max_resends (5) on node.rate_limit.
P(all 6 attempts fail) under 19% loss = 0.19^6 ≈ 0.005%.
Add the full next-hop routing algorithm to Node::find_next_hop():
- Local delivery, direct peer, bloom filter candidates, greedy tree
routing fallback, with (link_cost, tree_distance, node_addr) ordering
- select_best_candidate() scores by peer→dest distance (not us→peer)
with self-distance check to prevent routing loops
- TreeState::find_next_hop() for greedy tree routing with progress
guarantee
- ActivePeer::link_cost() placeholder (constant 1.0) for future link
quality metrics
Add routing tests including 100-node all-pairs reachability simulation
(9900/9900 delivered, 0 loops, avg 4.0 hops, max 8).
Update fips-routing.md to reflect bloom filter routing as the primary
forwarding mechanism, with greedy tree routing as fallback during
convergence windows.
When both nodes simultaneously initiate connections, each promotes its
inbound handshake first, leaving both sides with mismatched Noise sessions
and session indices. Resolve this in handle_msg2 using the existing
tie-breaker (smaller node_addr's outbound wins):
- Winner (smaller node): swaps ActivePeer to outbound session + indices
via new replace_session() method
- Loser (larger node): keeps inbound session and original their_index
(already references winner's outbound our_index from msg1)
Key insight: the loser must NOT update their_index from msg2, because the
msg2 sender_idx carries the winner's inbound index which becomes stale
after the winner swaps.
Defer outbound connection cleanup from promote_connection() to handle_msg2()
so outbound session state is available for the swap.
Verified with live two-node test over UDP in network namespaces: both nodes
connect, exchange TreeAnnounce, and converge to spanning tree within ~2s.
Fix promote_connection() to detect and clean up pending outbound
handshakes to the same peer, not just already-promoted peers. Previously,
when an inbound handshake completed while an outbound was still pending,
the outbound would linger until the 30s timeout.
Add auto-retry for failed outbound connections to auto-connect peers:
- New RetryState struct and node/retry.rs module
- Exponential backoff (default 5s base, max 5 attempts)
- Config: node.max_retries, node.base_retry_interval_secs
- check_timeouts() schedules retries, rx loop processes them
- promote_connection() clears retry state on success
- Remove unused PeerConnection retry fields (state now at Node level)
Move cleanup_stale_connection() logging to callers for context-appropriate
messages.
289 tests pass, clean build.
Rename NodeId to NodeAddr and npub to pubkey throughout documentation
and source code for consistency with the established identity model.
Add FIPS API vs IPv6 adapter overview to session protocol document.
Add transport address terminology note to wire protocol document.
Johnathan Corgan