Four sites where a check could report a verdict it had not established, or
detect a failure and then not turn it red.
assert_no_panic in both NAT suites read `docker logs ... || true`, so a
container that could not be read produced empty output, matched no panic
pattern, and returned success. The assertion's failure mode was
indistinguishable from its success condition. It now reports that absence of
panics is not established.
deb-install's apt capture discarded the exit status, so a failed docker exec
gave an empty capture that matched neither error pattern and reached the pass
branch. The status is now kept and checked before the output is inspected, with
the output still printed on failure.
wait_for_systemd printed a warning and returned success on timeout, so every
check after it read a system that may not have started its units. It now returns
non-zero and the caller abandons that distro leg rather than testing an
unstarted system.
interop's copy of count_log_pattern carried the same defect fixed in rekey: a
node whose logs could not be read contributed zero to eight expect-zero
assertions. Fixed the same way, and its consumer now reports the unreadable case
rather than comparing a sentinel against zero.
Each validated by breaking what it guards and by confirming the healthy path is
unchanged: an absent container now fails each check where it previously passed,
a readable panic-free container still passes, a real panic is still caught, and
a genuinely successful install still passes.
A test that greps the daemon's log for a message the daemon stopped emitting
does not fail. It stops observing, and an assertion built on it — especially
one expecting a count of zero — then passes because nothing can be seen
rather than because nothing happened. Several findings have come from that
one class, so it is now checked mechanically.
testing/check-log-strings.py extracts the strings test code matches against
daemon log text and requires each to exist in src/. It reads four shapes:
python `"..." in line` tests, the first argument of the shell log helpers,
bash associative-array pattern tables, and greps whose input is daemon log
output. Patterns carry regex syntax, so each is reduced to the longest
literal run of every alternation branch, with escaping resolved in the same
pass — `\.` is a literal dot and `.` is a wildcard, and conflating them would
let a pattern match text that is not there.
Scoping is by what a grep READS, not by what its file mentions. A suite greps
its own analyzer output, fipsctl JSON, Tor's log and ping output, and none of
those have to correspond to a string in src/; scoping on the file produced 34
false positives. Strings that legitimately do not come from src/ are named in
ALLOWED with a reason, so the exceptions are reviewable rather than invisible.
It found six dead strings, three of which were not previously known: a second
copy of "Excessive decrypt failures" in the interop pattern table, a dead
"Handshake error" branch inside an alternation whose other branches still
matched, and "bootstrap failed" in the NAT suite. All six are corrected to
what the daemon emits, or dropped where the surviving branch already covers
the case. Verified by breaking it two ways and confirming it reports.
Also here, since it is the same failure shape one layer down: the shared log
library returned an empty string for a container whose logs it could not
read, so analysing a missing container reported no panics, no errors and no
sessions, and exited 0 — indistinguishable from a clean run. It now reports
which containers could not be read and raises, matching the fix already
landed in the chaos copy.
Replace the fixed post-first-rekey and post-second-rekey settle sleeps in
the rekey integration test, and the fixed-deadline baseline wait in the
interop test, with the deterministic wait_until_connected progress-aware
polling helper already used for the initial baseline convergence.
Each converted site fails fast with structured diagnostics when the mesh
is stuck and extends its deadline only while pairwise reachability is
still climbing, removing the wall-clock settle windows that produced
intermittent connectivity failures after a rekey.
The interop harness only tested a full mesh, where every pair is a direct
one-hop FMP link. That left multi-hop forwarding, routing, coordinate
handling, and mesh-size estimation untested across versions.
Add an opt-in multi-hop topology and three new checks:
- generate-configs.sh: FIPS_INTEROP_EDGES selects an explicit undirected
edge list instead of the full mesh, with symmetric peering, connectivity
validation (no isolated node, graph connected), and per-node degree plus
edge metadata in nodes.env. Unset means full mesh, unchanged.
- interop-test.sh: a --topology flag with a built-in multihop-3v-cycle
(six nodes, two of each version, one cycle, two leaves). The per-node
peer check now expects each node's adjacency degree rather than N-1, and
the all-pairs ping now also exercises cross-version forwarding over
non-adjacent pairs. Adds a control-differential data-plane continuity
stream across the rekey window (Phase 5b) and a strict plus/minus 25
percent mesh-size convergence check (Phase 7).
- interop-stress.sh: forward --topology through to the per-rep driver
(mutually exclusive with a positional node-spec).
Phase 1 makes the strict retrying ping authoritative. The convergence
detector (one fully-clean, no-retry sweep of every directed pair) is now an
advisory settle-wait whose timeout is non-fatal; the strict retrying ping
decides pass/fail, matching how the post-rekey phases already work. Under
packet loss a clean no-retry sweep of a large mesh is statistically unlikely
even when the mesh is healthy (30 pairs at 2 percent loss leaves only about
55 percent of sweeps clean), so the detector otherwise falsely failed runs
whose strict ping reported full reachability. CONVERGENCE_TIMEOUT is now
env-overridable and defaults to 90s for larger meshes under loss.
Full-mesh runs are unaffected. Validated end-to-end with the
multihop-3v-cycle topology across three versions: all 30 directed pairs
reachable including multi-hop routed pairs, zero data-plane loss through
both rekey cutovers, and mesh-size converging to the true node count on
every node.
Johnathan Corgan