mirror of
https://github.com/vitorpamplona/amethyst.git
synced 2026-10-05 19:28:25 +00:00
Vitor PamplonaandClaude Opus 5
e184db69c7
Checked while asking whether the amethyst-nostr cask's review feedback applied
to the two formulae. It does not — but running homebrew-core's own linter over
them turned up a real defect neither had been checked for.
**The style violation, in both files.** `brew style` flags
Homebrew/FormulaPathMethods: Use formula_opt_prefix("openjdk")
instead of Formula["openjdk"].opt_prefix
on the `write_env_script` line. Fixed in `amy.rb` and `geode.rb`; both now
report no offenses. It would have been raised on submission.
**A duplicated sentence.** amy.rb opened with "Reference Homebrew formula for
`amy`, the Amethyst CLI." twice, once on line 1 and again on line 3.
**Why they must NOT be made to match the cask.** The cask lost its `livecheck`
block and inline comments on review, so the obvious next step is to do the same
here. That would be wrong, and the header now says so with the evidence:
homebrew-cask and homebrew-core differ. Sampling the live core tap, 127 of 300
formulae with GitHub-release URLs declare `livecheck` (62 using
`:github_latest`), and 109 of 200 carry indented inline comments. `livecheck`
is load-bearing in core — it is what lets BrewTestBot open version-bump PRs, so
stripping it would disable exactly the automation the block exists for.
**geode cannot be submitted under that name.** homebrew-core's
`formula_renames.json` maps "geode" -> "apache-geode", so the token is
permanently reserved and `brew info --formula geode` resolves to Apache Geode.
Submitting needs a different token (`geode-relay`, `amethyst-geode`) plus a
matching change to bump-homebrew-geode-formula.yml. Recorded as a blocker in
the header rather than discovered at PR time.
**amy is unblocked but not ready.** The one-open-AI-PR limit that gated it is
cleared now the cask has merged; the ~70 MB bundle from `:commons` pulling
Compose/Skiko onto the CLI classpath is still the likely review objection, and
`brew audit --new --formula` has not been run end to end.
Verified the enlarged headers cannot confuse the bump workflows: both anchor on
`^ url ` / `^ sha256 ` at a two-space indent, each matches exactly once, and
replaying their `sed` changes those two lines only. `ruby -c` passes on both.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Gs2gi3sZfQ7SHrVm2njLMw