amethyst/desktopApp/plans/2026-07-24-moderation-ux-manual-testing-sheet.md

Manual Testing Sheet — Moderation UX & Reporting (discoverability + feedback)

Covers the follow-on UX fixes: right-click note menu, the ⋮ overflow, and the new moderation publish logging. Companion to the full feature sheet (2026-07-23-desktop-moderation-safety-manual-testing-sheet.md).

Branch: worktree-feat-desktop-moderation-safety (commit 65579ff or later) Run: ./gradlew :desktopApp:run Watch the log (this terminal, or desktop-run*.log) — moderation actions now print a line tagged [Moderation].

Legend: P pass · F fail (note it) · B blocked.

---

0. Preconditions

• Logged in with a writeable account (local nsec, or a connected bunker).
• At least one relay connected — check the relay indicator. This matters: a report/mute publishes to connected relays only; with 0 connected it is logged as not delivered.
• Have another user X's notes visible in a feed.

---

1. Discoverability — how to reach the actions

#	Steps	Expected	Result
D1	Look at a note's action row (reply / ♥ / repost / zap / bookmark / ⋮)	The last icon is now a ⋮ (three dots), not a share arrow
D2	Left-click the ⋮	Menu opens: Copy Text / Copy Note ID / Copy Event Link / Copy Raw JSON / Copy Web Link / Broadcast / Mute user / Report…
D3	Right-click anywhere on a note	Context menu opens: Copy text / Mute user / Report…
D4	Right-click your own note	Only Copy text (no Mute/Report on yourself)
D5	Open another user's profile → header shows a ⋮ next to Follow → click it	Mute/Unmute user + Report…
D6	On a read-only (npub) login, repeat D2/D3	Only Copy items; no Mute/Report

---

2. Report (NIP-56) — with verifiable feedback

Do each, then check the log line.

#	Steps	Expected + log signal	Result
R1	⋮ (or right-click) → Report…	Dialog: reason radios + comment + Report / Block & report / Cancel
R2	Pick a reason → Report	Log shows [Moderation] report(<reason>) kind=1984 id=… → N relays (N ≥ 1)
R3	Confirm on a relay (optional)	A kind-1984 event by you, tagging the note id + author, exists on relay
R4	Report a user from profile ⋮ → Report…	Log: [Moderation] report-user(<reason>) kind=1984 id=… → N relays
R5	Block & report	Two log lines: report(...) and mute+ kind=10000 …; author's notes vanish
R6	Disconnect all relays, then Report	Log WARN: … → 0 connected relays (not delivered) — proves the "silent failure" is now visible

There is no success snackbar yet — confirmation is via the [Moderation] log line (and the author disappearing for mutes). A toast/snackbar is a noted follow-up; see "Known gaps" below.

---

3. Mute / unmute — live effect + log

#	Steps	Expected + log	Result
M1	⋮ / right-click X's note → Mute user	X's notes disappear from the feed live; log [Moderation] mute+ kind=10000 id=… → N relays
M2	Settings → Content Filters → Moderation & Safety → Muted users	X is listed with a display name + Unmute
M3	Click Unmute	X reappears live; log [Moderation] mute- kind=10000 … → N relays
M4	Hidden words → type a word → Add	Notes with the word collapse; log mute+ kind=10000
M5	Profile ⋮ → Mute user, reopen menu	Label now reads Unmute user

---

4. Content warning (NIP-36) — sanity

#	Steps	Expected	Result
C1	Sensitive/CW-tagged note in feed	Collapsed "Sensitive content" + reason + Show
C2	Settings → Moderation & Safety → toggle Always show sensitive content ON	CW notes render unblurred; persists after app restart

---

5. Log reference

While testing, moderation lines look like:

INFO: [Moderation] mute+ kind=10000 id=3f9a1c02 → 4 relays
INFO: [Moderation] report(spam) kind=1984 id=9b7e4410 → 4 relays
WARNING: [Moderation] report(spam) kind=1984 id=9b7e4410 → 0 connected relays (not delivered)
WARNING: [Moderation] report failed: <signer error>

• → N relays (N≥1) = published. → 0 connected relays = you had no relay connected; reconnect and retry. report failed: = signing/publish threw (e.g. bunker rejected/timed out).

---

Known gaps (not bugs — noted follow-ups)

• No success snackbar/toast — feedback is via the log line + the muted author disappearing. A user-facing confirmation is a small follow-up (needs a SnackbarHostState threaded to the note card / dialog).
• Reports are broadcast to connected relays (not a NIP-56 outbox split).

Sign-off

• ⋮ overflow + right-click both reach Mute/Report (§1).
• Report logs a → N relays line with N ≥ 1 (§2 R2/R4).
• Zero-relay report is logged as not-delivered (§2 R6).
• Mute hides live + shows in management screen + unmute restores (§3).

Overall: ☐ PASS ☐ FAIL — notes: __________________________________________